Medigap Plan F Versus High Deductible Plan F

Medicare Supplement (Medigap) High Deductible Plan F suffers from a horrible name, but don’t overlook it.  The premiums can be very affordable and the coverage is better than the name suggests.

Let’s begin with shortening up Medicare Supplement (Medigap) High Deductible Plan F for readability.  Let’s use HD-F from now on.


Next, let’s make sure you understand with the word – deductible.  A deductible is the amount you pay each year before your health insurer begins to cover your medical services.

The deductible in 2016 for HD-F is $2,180.

Just to be crystal clear, this means before your Medicare Supplement insurance company pays anyone or anything… the first $2,180 is out of your wallet.

The thing is, the deductible really isn’t all that high, especially when you compare it to what they are in individual ACA (Obamacare) plans.  Right now, the average the average combined deductible for 2016 is $5,765 for bronze plans (up from $5,328 in 2015) and $3,064 for silver plans (up from $2,556 in 2015).  So, if you’re currently paying for your own individual coverage, odds are $2,180 doesn’t scare you.

If it does, I’m about to show you how the differences between premiums for these plans can more than pay for the deductible in a very short amount of time.


Then there’s the price: They’re cheap.  Obviously, prices vary from state to state and carrier to carrier, but they’re generally half – if not less than half the price of a regular Medicare (Medigap) Supplement Plan F.

Let’s take a look at both of them side-by side (premiums are illustrative only).  Here’s a hint:  The only things different are the monthly premium and MOOP!

We’ll start first with Medigap Plan F

Medicare SupplementPlan F
Monthly Premium$180 per month
Annual Deductible ExpenseNone
Annual Coinsurance ExpenseNone
Annual Maximum Out-of-Pocket (MOOP)Zero
NetworkYou can see any doctor who accepts your coverage; no referrals needed for specialists
Other Out-of-pocket CostsNo copays for doctor's visits or hospitalization
Prescription Drugs Does not include prescription drug coverage

Well, that was nice.  Let’s now look at Medigap HD-F

Medicare SupplementHigh Deductible F
Monthly Premium$80 per month
Annual Deductible Expense$2,180
Annual Coinsurance ExpenseNone
Annual Maximum Out-of-Pocket (MOOP)$2,180
NetworkYou can see any doctor who accepts your coverage; no referrals needed for specialists
Other Out-of-pocket CostsNo copays for doctor's visits or hospitalization
Prescription Drugs Does not include prescription drug coverage

Break Even

I’ve done a bit of quick math for you below.  If you assume a monthly premium of $180 for Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plan F, and an $80 monthly premium for HD-F, the chart shows you’ll break even in a little under 2 years.  Another way of saying that, is: by paying less monthly premium for HD-F, you’ll effectively save enough money (if you don’t use it) to cover the deductible in just under years.

 Medicare Supplement Plan F Monthly PremiumMedicare Supplement HD-F Monthly Premium
Total Annual Premium Cost$2160$960
Annual Savings$1200
Number of Years to Break Even1.81

But there’s yet another way of thinking about this: If you buy an HD-F when you turn 65, by the time you turn 67 you will have already saved enough money to cover an entire yearly deductible.  By the time you’re 69, you’ve already got more than two and on your way to three year’s worth of maximum deductibles saved up.

The Takeaway

So, which one is the right choice for you?  To get there, the central questions you must ask yourself (and answer) are these:

  1.  Do I want to give the insurance company $180 per month for 100% coverage and 100% peace of mind?
  2. Or do I want to give them $80, save $100 a month in premium and stick that $100 it in my back pocket just in case I get sick and need it?
  3. Should I just go with a Medicare Advantage plan?


Medicare Supplement Plan F and the Medicare Excess Charge

Medicare Supplement Plan F, also known as Medigap Plan F, is and has been by far the most popular plan purchased by seniors looking for the most complete Medicare coverage. It’s also the most expensive, with premiums ranging from $150-$250 per person, per month. I say most complete, because Plan F pays the rest of the charges Original Medicare doesn’t charge plus an additional amount called, “excess charges.” What are excess charges? The vast majority of doctors and hospitals across the country accept what’s called, “Medicare Assignment.”

What is Medicare Assignment?

In plain English, that means Medicare says they’ll pay them a certain amount for a procedure or a doctor’s visit, and those doctors and hospitals essentially say, “OK.” These folks are considered to be “participating” in Medicare. In return, they’re not allowed to bill the person receiving medical care any additional amounts. If the doctor, hospital or facility does NOT accept Medicare Assignment (non-participating) they can still bill Medicare, get paid and then bill YOU an additional 15% above and beyond what Medicare paid them. This is called the Medicare Excess Charge. Of course, doctors and hospitals that opt out of Medicare altogether can bill you whatever they want.

Before you get all worried about these charges, it’s important to put them in perspective. Over 99% of doctors and hospitals across the country accept Medicare Assignment. The doctors and hospitals that don’t are usually specialty cancer centers or research institutions.

The Takeaway

Medicare Supplement Plan F is the only Medicare supplement product that covers that additional 15% should you need it. Odds are you won’t, but if you like that security blanket (and it seems many do, based on the popularity) then Medicare Supplement Plan F is for you.

Of course, and this is true with all Medicare Supplement buyers, most folks buy these because they want the freedom to choose any doctor or hospital they want, don’t want the hassle of a network (PPO or HMO) and they can afford the monthly premium.

One last note: Medicare Supplement Plan C (second most popular plan) is essentially Plan F, without the excess charge coverage. If there’s a meaningful difference in premium between the two in your state and your doctors and hospitals take Medicare assignment, it may make sense to go that route.